Being right

“Being right is not a fruit of the Spirit.”

This mic drop piece of wisdom was given to me around age 30 by my pastor at the time and has stuck with me ever since. Even before that, I had an inkling that maybe I didn’t know too much.

I’m talking mostly about theological disagreements between denominations, to be specific. I grew up in a Southern Baptist tradition, and my parents joined a more fundamentalist church when I was in college - a Reformed Presbyterian college that was not on their approved list. I attended a church in Haiti where missionaries of every stripe and color also attended, so I was worshiping with charismatics, Presbyterians, Catholics, Mennonites, Baptists, Dutch Reformed, you name it. Those early years of my walk with Jesus were rich in exposure to many different expressions of faith in Christ.

I remember my freshman year at Geneva College meeting people who had interpretations of certain scriptures about worship, for example, that were quite different than my own. Teachings that I had heard in my home church about baptism and the end times, were challenged by other views on these subjects. I saw more emphases on things like grace at Geneva, while holiness was more of a theme at home.

Overall, though, my takeaway was that people in both camps loved God and were serious about their faith. I learned that no one has a “corner on the market” of total understanding. Unfortunately, I also ran into a lot of judgement across the aisle, one group thinking more highly of their own interpretations than they should have.

I continue to see this. It is disheartening when someone who has truly been touched by God is so blind to the need for humility about biblical interpretations. But it is not new and we can find guidance and hope through the scriptures and church history.

This morning, in my devotions about great prayers, I learned about Hilda of Whitby, from the 600’s (it is always amazing how church historians can find these somewhat obscure stories from so very long ago). She clearly prayed for wisdom and understanding because both ordinary folk and nobility came to her for guidance. Proverbs 4:7 and other scriptures urge us to “get wisdom…get understanding, to ask of God and He will give it.”

One of Hilda’s great accomplishments as the leader of an abbey in the north of England, was to host a gathering to broker the complex relationship between two factions of the Christian faith: one following in the traditions of Celtic Christians and the other a group of Roman Christians immigrating to the area. I truly have no idea what their disagreements were. I can imagine they may have been over the same things we are still disputing today. Maybe the Romans wanted to serve Chianti at communion and the Celts were like, no way are we serving alcohol in church.

It was encouraging to read about her today, about this great meeting between two groups of Jesus followers who came from very different cultures, many thousands of miles apart from each other. The struggles we have with fellow believers are not new. And there will always be these disputes.

How we navigate these disagreements and the posture of our hearts is the real test: can we remain in a humble position, and say, I probably don’t fully understand this, and I may be wrong. I’d love to hear your thoughts on the matter. This shows great strength and wisdom.

On the other hand, when I person asserts himself, drawing a line in the sand and stating, I am right, and you are wrong, then humility is severely lacking, the person seems desperate to win, and wisdom is nowhere to be found.

I have found that fear is actually beneath the assertion of right-ness. If I can create this box in which my theology can safely live, then I don’t need to fear being tossed about by every wind of doctrine (Ephesians 4:14). Unfortunately, that leaves a person stunted as a legend in their own mind, unable to grow and be stretched by others, or by experiences that challenge their views. And the scripture about winds of doctrine is speaking of evil people who are deliberately trying to deceive the weak in faith, not Christ followers trying to unpack the Scriptures.

Our modern world gives us plenty of opportunity to judge our brothers and sisters in Christ from different perspectives - we can pull up the website or YouTube channel of almost any church and see what their statement of faith is, or view a worship service online. We watch 30 second Instagram clips of someone expressing their thoughts on gifts of the Holy Spirit. It is easy and weak to make a judgement call based on these brief disembodied glimpses.

But could we come together like the Celts and the Romans in the 600’s and really talk things out, getting wisdom, getting understanding? Ah, for more humility. Wouldn’t that be nice?

Next
Next

We are all counselors